At a glance
| Injections (Mounjaro, Wegovy) | Gastric sleeve | |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | Hormone-like medicine that reduces appetite and slows digestion | Removes about 75–80% of the stomach, reducing capacity and hunger hormones |
| Average weight loss | Around 15–20% of body weight in trials | Around 25–30% of body weight |
| How long it lasts | While you keep taking it | Permanent change to the stomach; habits decide the long-term result |
| Commitment | Weekly injection, often indefinitely | One operation, then lifelong diet changes and vitamins |
| Main downsides | Nausea, constipation, cost, regain after stopping | Surgical risks, reflux in some people, irreversible |
How each one works
Mounjaro (tirzepatide) and Wegovy (semaglutide) copy gut hormones that signal fullness. You feel less hungry, food stays in the stomach longer and cravings quieten. They are injected once a week, with the dose increased gradually over months.
A gastric sleeve is keyhole surgery that removes most of the stomach, leaving a narrow tube. You fill up on far smaller portions, and levels of ghrelin, the main hunger hormone, fall. It is the most common weight-loss operation worldwide.
Results: what the evidence shows
Injections narrowed the gap with surgery, but surgery still leads on average weight loss.
- Wegovy: in the main trial, people lost on average about 15% of their body weight over 68 weeks.
- Mounjaro: on the highest dose, average weight loss was about 20% over 72 weeks.
- Gastric sleeve: typically 25–30% of total body weight within one to two years, with long-term data stretching over a decade.
Averages hide a wide range. Some people respond strongly to injections, others much less. Surgery results also vary, and some weight returns over the years if eating habits slip. For someone with a BMI of 45, the difference between 15% and 30% loss is large; for someone with a BMI of 32, injections may be enough.
What happens when you stop
This is the most important difference. In trials where people stopped weight-loss injections, appetite came back and much of the lost weight returned within a year; in one well-known study, around two-thirds. Doctors increasingly treat these medicines as long-term or lifelong treatment, much like medication for blood pressure.
A sleeve cannot be 'stopped'. The smaller stomach stays, although it can stretch over time if portions creep up. The long-term result depends on habits, which is why good bariatric programmes include dietitian support. Our gastric sleeve vs gastric bypass guide covers long-term results in more detail.
Cost over five years
NHS access to weight-loss injections is limited and being rolled out in phases, with priority for people with a high BMI and several weight-related conditions. Most people in the UK who use them pay privately, commonly around £150–£330 a month depending on the medicine, dose and pharmacy.
| 1 year | 3 years | 5 years | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weight-loss injections | £1,800–£4,000 | £5,400–£12,000 | £9,000–£20,000 |
| Gastric sleeve in Istanbul | £2,900–£3,800 once, plus flights and vitamins | No further surgery cost | No further surgery cost |
| Gastric sleeve, private UK | £8,700–£13,500 once | No further surgery cost | No further surgery cost |
Prices for injections change and vary between pharmacies, so treat these as a guide. Surgery also brings costs of its own: lifelong vitamin supplements and follow-up blood tests.
Who suits which
The right answer depends on your BMI, your health and how you feel about long-term medication versus surgery.
Injections may suit you if
- Your BMI is in the 30s and you need to lose a moderate amount
- You would rather avoid surgery, or surgery is not safe for you
- You are comfortable with long-term medication and its cost
A gastric sleeve may suit you if
- Your BMI is 40 or above, or 35 or above with a condition such as type 2 diabetes, sleep apnoea or high blood pressure
- Injections did not work, caused side effects, or the weight returned after stopping
- You want a one-off treatment rather than indefinite medication
Not sure where you sit? Check your BMI against the usual surgery criteria with the calculator below. If surgery is not for you, a gastric balloon or gastric botox are non-surgical options with shorter-term effects.
Loading the tool…
Using both
Injections and surgery are increasingly used together. Some surgeons use them before an operation to reduce liver size and surgical risk, and they can help people who regain weight years after surgery. If you are taking a weight-loss injection, tell your surgical team: these medicines slow stomach emptying, which matters for anaesthesia, and you may be asked to pause them before the operation.
If you regained weight after a previous operation, revision surgery is another route to discuss.
Side effects and risks
- Injections: nausea, vomiting, constipation or diarrhoea are common, especially when the dose increases. Rarer risks include gallbladder problems and pancreatitis. Buy only from regulated prescribers and pharmacies.
- Sleeve: the main surgical risks are bleeding, a leak from the staple line and blood clots, all uncommon in experienced hands. Some people develop reflux. Vitamin supplements are needed for life.
Frequently asked questions
Neither is better for everyone. Mounjaro leads to around 20% average weight loss on the highest dose while you keep taking it; a sleeve typically leads to 25–30% and does not depend on ongoing medication. Your BMI, health and preferences decide.
Yes. Many people consider surgery after injections stop working or the weight returns. Tell your surgeon, as you may need to pause the medicine before the operation.
Many people do. In trials, much of the lost weight returned within a year of stopping, which is why the injections are increasingly seen as long-term treatment.
Sometimes, if weight returns years later. This is a decision for your doctor, who will weigh it against options such as dietitian support or revision surgery.
Usually 40 or above, or 35 or above with a weight-related condition such as type 2 diabetes, sleep apnoea or high blood pressure. A surgeon reviews every case individually.